Text 25681, 95 rader
Skriven 2012-02-24 12:34:39 av Herman Neut (2:280/1141)
  Kommentar till text 25678 av Dale Shipp (1:261/1466.0)
Ärende: Re: Fidonews v29, n8 mes
================================
Hi Dale,


   Quoting: Dale Shipp to Roy Witt
 Date/Time: 24-Feb-12 / 00:24:02
   Subject: Re: Fidonews v29, n8 mes


 DS> All messages were there on the first three nodes.  They were not
 DS> there on the last node, ergo it is that node that killed them.  It
 DS> was not Janis that did it -- it was Björn.

 DS>> And based on the path to Björn, there are only two suspects as to
 DS>> who eliminated the messages by mistake and prevented them from
 DS>> reaching his system.

 RW>> Not! The path from/to Neut's system to Björn's system doesn't
 RW>> exist until Seaborn gets a packet from Neut. Then that pkt
 RW>> travels through 140/1 to Ross at 123/500 who is linked with
 RW>> 320/119, Andrew Leary, who then passes it to Björn, who passes it
 RW>> along to Michiel which then goes to Australia and back to Z1 to
 RW>> several links here. If you ask any of them in that path, they
 RW>> won't have seen it either, unless those 12 messages made it from
 RW>> 261/38 to 3:712/848 which is a 'repeater' serving Z1 and Z2.

 DS> I was not talking about messages from Neut, and so that convoluted
 DS> chain you name is not relevant.  We were talking about messages
 DS> from Nick, and how they should have gotten to Björn.  As confirmed
 DS> in todays mail, they got to 320/119 but not to Björn.

-----

 DS> I've seen no evidence from you -- and you have ignored what I was
 DS> saying.  Maybe now you will understand it.
 RW>> The path as I think Herman would see it is; Herman, Seaborn <>
 RW>> Seaborn, Herman.

 DS> Herman's path is irrelevant to how Björn should have gotten the
 DS> messages from Nick.  He got them, but must have tossed them out as
 DS> dupes.

 RW>> The path that shows how they got from his system to mine is quite
 RW>> long; herman, seaborn, ross, leary, crosses the Atlantic to;
 RW>> felten, vd Vlist, little to me.

 RW>> Not being able to correctly read a path line may be your cause of
 RW>> confusion.

 DS> Did you read the path line on the message from Nick to Björn?  It
 DS> is quite simple, as I have been saying.  It is all that is
 DS> relevant to my discussion.


This is my pathline from Nick to me:

@PATH: 261/1406 38 140/1

I _only_ received:
T h e   F i d o N e w s   Volume 29   Number 08        February 20, 2012
Contents page.

The other pages never arrived here.

Even Bob Seaborn didn't get those pages.


From the frontpage (I received):

@SEENBY: 120/544 123/500 124/311 138/146 140/1 12 14 17 18 153/7715 261/38
@SEENBY: 266/512 275/100 280/1141 288/34 342/16 77 382/61 772/1 3828/7 5020/715
@SEENBY: 7105/1
@PATH: 261/1406 38 140/1

Where was the bottleneck?  Janis? I don't think so......
Bob? No, he did not receive the other pages.......

And I didnot receive dupes!
The International FidoNews Volume 29 Number 08 arrived on my system the day
after I did read the Z1 version (only front page)

Do you think Björn Felten cracked Janis her, or Bob his system???????





Best Regards,
      Herman Neut

 e-mail: h.neutnospam@hccnet.nl
 Skype: herman_neut


--- Terminate 5.00/Pro & BinkD/0.9.7-stable/Powered by WinXP
 * Origin: Ster in Twente -Haaksbergen-The Netherlands (2:280/1141)