Text 1088, 116 rader
Skriven 2012-07-22 16:20:02 av mark lewis (1:3634/12.0)
   Kommentar till text 1057 av Rob Swindell (138627.fidonews)
Ärende: MSG-IDs
===============
 > should i also point out that synchronet is generating REPLY control lines
 > for posts that have no MSGID in them? this is definitely not right...

 RS> Well, I looked into it and the only thing I can find that is
 RS> "definitely not right" is your claim.

then you either don't have the messages demonstrating this or you've missed
something somewhere... to be specific, and i'm looking for the messages now,
nick andre wrote a message... his software doesn't generate MSGIDs at all...
nick boel replied to that message and nickB's reply carries a bogus REPLY
control line generated by synchronet... in fact, while looking back, i came
across one of your replies to one of nickA's posts and your's, too, carries a
bogus REPLY line generated by synchronet...

FWIW: i noticed this because the messages were not linked... my software links
messages by MSGID/REPLY... i wondered why nickA's weren't being linked so i
looked and there is no MSGID or REPLY lines in his posts... then i looked at
others' who had replied and i discovered this bug... i mentioned it at least
once to nickB... maybe twice... then i mentioned it to you and here we are ;)

 RS> I can find no evidence of what you described actually ocurring, nor
 RS> could I reproduce your claimed behavior. Double-checking the
 RS> Synchronet source code confirms that the FTN REPLY kludge line is
 RS> only created/added if the message being replied to has an FTN
 RS> MSGID:

ahhh... found nickA's to me and your reply to him... some text included to
assist in memory of or locating the message(s) in question... "pestering Scot
Dudley" made a perfect search term in my other editor i used to find them with
while i was writting this... there are several others with the same text from
nickA ;)

[QUOTE="Nick Andre replied to Mark LEwis"]
====[ FIDONEWS ]==============================================================
On: Mon 16 Jul 2012 16:08    (Rcvd: Wed 18 Jul 2012  0:06)              #83013
By: Nick Andre
To: Mark Lewis
Re: Re: .fidonet
St: Rcvd
==============================================================================
@SEEN-BY: 18/0 109/500 112/0 114/487 116/116 123/0 52 57 140 456 500 789 880
@SEEN-BY: 123/1011 1025 6502 124/5013 135/1313 137/10 140/1 226/600 250/100
@SEEN-BY: 261/38 1466 266/420 298/5 320/119 322/320 759 323/120 3634/12
@PATH: 229/426 280/5555 292/854 123/500
On 16 Jul 12  14:58:20, Mark Lewis said the following to Nick Andre:

ML> added to existing quotes being quoted again... all of this took place over
ML> some 10 years by my rough reckoning... and that was 15 to 20 years ago at
ML> least! back in a time when you were doing what in this hobby?

In Fidonet, actually, 15-20 years ago. Again, research before you rant. 
Careful, I may be busy pestering Scott Dudley for source code.

[CHOMP by ml]

Nick

-!- Renegade vY2Ka2
 - Origin: www.darkrealms.ca (1:229/426)
[/QUOTE]


[QUOTE="Rob Swindell's reply to Nick Andre"]
====[ FIDONEWS ]==============================================================
On: Tue 17 Jul 2012  8:32    (Arrd: Tue 17 Jul 2012 13:02)              #83053
By: Rob Swindell
To: Nick Andre
Re: Re: .fidonet
St: 
==============================================================================
@TZUTC: -0700
@MSGID: 138377.fidonews@1:103/705 146cd824
@REPLY: 138290.fidonews@1:103/705 146c5753
@PID: Synchronet 3.16a-Win32  Debug Jun 13 201
@TID: SBBSecho 2.13-Win32 r1.208 Feb 25 2012 MSC 1600
@SEEN-BY: 10/0 1 11/200 331 18/0 102/943 103/0 17 705 109/500 112/0 114/487
@SEEN-BY: 116/116 120/544 123/0 52 57 140 456 500 789 880 1011 1025 6502
@SEEN-BY: 124/5013 128/2 187 135/364 1313 137/10 138/146 140/1 30 143/0 1 103
@SEEN-BY: 202/0 207/0 210 208/0 213/0 214/1 218/0 1 504 700 222/2 226/0 600
@SEEN-BY: 230/150 240/5832 249/303 250/1 100 306 261/20 38 100 1381 1406 1466
@SEEN-BY: 266/420 1413 267/155 280/1027 292/907 298/5 311/2 320/119 219 322/320
@SEEN-BY: 322/759 323/120 340/400 345/0 393/68 396/45 633/260 712/848 801/161
@SEEN-BY: 801/189 3634/12 5030/709 1256
@PATH: 103/705 10/1 261/38 123/500
  Re: Re: .fidonet
  By: Nick Andre to Mark Lewis on Mon Jul 16 2012 04:08 pm

 > Careful, I may be busy pestering Scott Dudley for source code.

The Maximus and Squish source has been publically (and legally) available 
since 
2002: http://sourceforge.net/projects/maximus/

Or were you talking about a different Scott Dudley?

                                            digital man

Synchronet "Real Fact" #2:
Synchronet version 2 was written in C and 8086 assembly programming languages.
Norco, CA WX: 61.2øF, 79.0% humidity, 0 mph SE wind, 0.00 inches rain/24hrs
-!- SBBSecho 2.13-Win32
 - Origin: Vertrauen - vert.synchro.net (1:103/705)
[/QUOTE]

i can continue to look for the others, too, if you wish... but the above ought
to be enough for you to find them in your message bases and take it from there
;)

FWIW: i can also dig them out of my PKTs archives... all inbound mail is
retained here for up to 30 days specifically for diagnostic purposes like this
and especially when/if someone needs/wants to see what the raw PKTs carry so as
to ensure that other software, like an editor, didn't screw something up...

)\/(ark

 * Origin:  (1:3634/12)